THE NEW YORK TIMES OP-ED THURSDAY AUGUST 18, 2005                   YT    A23

_BOB HERBERT

Blood Runs Red, Not Blue

  You have to wonder whether reality
ever comes knocking on George W.
Bush's door. If it did, would the presi-
dent with the unsettling demeanor of a
boy king even bother to answer? Mr.
Bush is the commander in chief who
launched a savage war in Iraq and
now spends his days happily riding his
bicycle in Texas.
  This is eerie. Scary. Surreal.
  The war is going badly and lives
have been lost by the thousands, but
there is no real sense, either at the
highest levels of government or in the
nation at large, that anything mo-
mentous is at stake. The announce-
ment on Sunday that five more Ameri-
can soldiers had been blown to eterni-
ty by roadside bombs was treated by
the press as a yawner. It got very little
attention.
  You can turn on the television any
evening and tune in to the bizarre ex-
tended coverage of the search for Na-
talee Holloway, the Alabama teenager
who disappeared in Aruba in May.
But we hear very little about the men
and women who have given up their lives
in Iraq, or are living with horrific inju-
ries suffered in that conflict.
  If only the war were more enter-
taining. Less of a downer. Perhaps
then we could meet the people who are
suffering and dying in it.
  For all the talk of supporting the
troops,they are a low priority for
most Americans. If the nation really
cared, the president would not be frol-
icking at his ranch for the entire
month of August. He'd be back in
Washington burning the midnight oil,
trying to figure out how to get the
troops out of the terrible fix he put
them in.
  Instead, Mr. Bush is bicycling as
soldiers and marines are dying. Doz-
ens have been killed since he went off
on his vacation.
  As for the rest of the nation, it's not
doing much for the troops, either.
There was a time, long ago, when war
required sacrifices that were shared
by most of the population. That's over.
  I was in Jacksonville, Fla., a few
days ago and watched in amusement
as a young woman emerged from a
restaurant into 95-degree heat and
gleefully exclaimed, "All right, let's go
shopping!"The war was the furthest
thing from her mind.
  For the most part, the only people
sacrificing for this war are the troops
and their families, and very few of
them are coming from the privileged
economic classes. That's why it's so

easy to keep the troops out of sight
and out of mind. And it's why, in the
third year of a war started by the rich-
est nation on earth, we still get stories
like the one in Sunday's Times that be-
gan:
  "For the second time since the Iraq
war began, the Pentagon is struggling
to replace body armor that is failing
to protect American troops from the
most lethal attacks by insurgents."
  Scandalous incompetence? Appall-
ing indifference? Try both. Who
cares? This is a war fought mostly by
other people's children. The loudest of
the hawks are the least likely to send
their sons or daughters off to Iraq.
  The president has never been clear
about why we're in Iraq. There's no

Is Iraq worth the
lives of the rich?


plan, no strategy. In one of the many
tragic echoes of Vietnam, U.S. troops
have been fighting hellacious battles
to seize areas controlled by insur-
gents, only to retreat and allow the in-
surgents to return.
  If Mr. Bush were willing to do some-
thing he has refused to do so far -
speak plainly and honestly to the
American people about this war - he
might be able to explain why U.S.
troops should continue with an effort
that is, in large part at least, bene-
fiting Iraqi factions that are murder-
ous, corrupt and terminally hostile to
women. If by some chance he could
make that case, the next appropriate
step would be to ask all Americans to
do their part for the war effort.
  College kids in the U.S. are playing
video games and looking forward to
frat parties while their less fortunate
peers are rattling around like moving
targets in Baghdad and Mosul, trying
to dodge improvised explosive devices
and rocket-propelled grenades.
  There is something very, very
wrong with this picture.
  If the war in Iraq is worth fighting
-if it's a noble venture, as the hawks
insist it is - then it's worth fighting
with the children of the privileged
classes. They should be added to the
combat mix. If it's not worth their
blood, then we should bring the other
troops home.
  If Mr. Bush's war in Iraq is worth
dying for, then the children of the priv-
ileged should be doing some of the dy-
ing.